Our Comparison

Key Control Without a Key Cabinet

Electronic key cabinets, such as KeyTrak and KeyWatcher, lock keys away and release each key only to an authorized person. ATD Key Management is software only: it records each key that you issue and get back, and works with the key storage that you have now.

Key Control Without a Key Cabinet: facts checked November 8, 2026
ATD Key ManagementElectronic key cabinets (KeyTrak, KeyWatcher)
What you buySoftware onlyKeyTrak Edge: a computerized locking steel drawer with iButton key tags. KeyWatcher: a key cabinet with SmartKeys.
Price$40 for each user each month, or $40 with yearly billingBy quote; no prices on the makers' websites
Locks keys until an authorized person signs inNo; it records each issue and returnYes
How people sign inOn a computer or a phoneAt the cabinet; KeyTrak Edge has a fingerprint reader
Overdue keysShown at the top of each page, with the name of each key holderKeyTrak: push alerts in its mobile app for overdue keys, open drawers, and power cuts
SetupSign up online; no installationInstallation on site
Keys that people keep for days or monthsYes, with a due date for each keyTracks each key as it leaves and returns to the cabinet

Two different jobs

A key cabinet controls keys that people take out and put back, often on the same day: vehicle keys at a dealership or a police station, or the keys for one building. Its strength is physical control. A key stays locked until an authorized person signs in.

ATD Key Management controls keys that people keep: keys for staff, contractors, tenants, and short-term rental guests, often for weeks or months, in many buildings. It shows who holds each key, when it is due back, and which keys are overdue.

Use both

Many organizations need both. Keep the keys that move each day in a cabinet. Record the keys that people keep in ATD Key Management.

Which One Is Right for You?

Choose ATD if

  • People keep keys for days, weeks, or months.
  • Your keys are in many buildings or sites.
  • You want to start this week, with no hardware to buy or install.
  • You manage a master key system and need a record of each level and each copy.

Choose a key cabinet if

  • Many people take the same keys out and put them back each day.
  • Keys must stay locked until an authorized person signs in.
  • The keys are in one place, such as a vehicle lot or a front desk.

Questions

Is key control software a replacement for a key cabinet?

Not always. A cabinet locks keys away. Software records who has each key. If your keys must stay locked until an authorized person signs in, you need a cabinet. If people keep keys for long periods, software is the better tool.

What does ATD Key Management cost?

$40 for each user each month, or $40 each month with yearly billing, for 3 to 10 users. The people who hold keys do not need to be users. There is no hardware to buy.

Sources

We checked these facts on November 8, 2026. Prices and plans change, so check each source before you decide.

Try ATD for Your Team

$40 per user each month, or $40 with yearly billing. No setup fees. Or book a call, and we answer your questions.

Calculate Your Price