Compare ATD With
Other Software
Every ATD product, compared with a well-known alternative. These are our own comparisons. Each one shows the facts that we checked, and when the other product is the better choice.
ATD Work Order Management vs UpKeep
Both are work order management software (CMMS). UpKeep has more features. ATD puts preventive maintenance, cost tracking, and a request link for people outside your team into one price. This page shows where each one is the better choice.
| ATD Work Order Management | UpKeep | |
|---|---|---|
| Published price for each user | $40 each month, or $40 each month with yearly billing | Essential $24 each month, Premium $55 each month; Professional and Enterprise by quote |
| Preventive maintenance scheduling | Included | Premium plan and above |
| Labor and cost tracking for each job | Included | Premium plan and above (time and labor tracking) |
| Request link for people outside your team | Included; no account needed | Professional plan and above (external request portal) |
| Parts and inventory management | Not included today | Premium plan and above |
| AI features | Not included | Nova AI credits on each plan |
| Mobile offline mode | Not included | Professional plan and above |
| Paid setup and training | No setup fee | Optional: $500 to $5,000 for training and implementation |
| Who needs a paid seat | Each person who signs in; people who only send requests need no account | Admins and technicians; requesters, view-only users, and vendors are free |
Choose ATD if
- You want preventive maintenance, cost tracking, and a public request link at one price.
- Your team has 3 to 10 people who use the system.
- You want to talk to the people who build the software.
- You may need custom changes later.
Choose UpKeep if
- Many supervisors must view reports without a paid seat.
- You must track spare parts and stock with costs.
- You want AI features or a mobile app that works offline.
- You run many sites and need integrations, single sign-on, and custom roles.
- You need only basic work orders at the lowest price per user.
This is our own comparison. Read the full comparison, with its sources and questions.
ATD Asset Tracking vs Asset Panda
Both are asset tracking and inventory software. They charge in opposite ways. ATD publishes one price for each user. Asset Panda prices by the number of records that you track, with unlimited users, and gives you a quote.
| ATD Asset Tracking | Asset Panda | |
|---|---|---|
| How the price is set | For each user | By the number of records that you track |
| Published price | $40 for each user each month, or $40 with yearly billing | No; you get a quote after a walkthrough |
| Users | Unlimited | Unlimited users |
| Charge for each asset | No | Yes; plans scale by record count |
| Free option | No | A free entry option, and a 7-day trial |
| Check-out and check-in | To people and locations, by barcode or QR scan, with a full history | By barcode or QR scan on a phone |
| Audits | Printed inventory checklists for each location | Counts and audits by scanning on a phone |
| Adding many assets | Import from Excel or CSV, with AI-assisted imports; asset tags and QR labels | Import from Excel or CSV, with AI-assisted imports; asset tags and labels |
| Works offline | Coming Soon | Yes; scans sync when the connection returns |
| Maintenance and work orders | Integrates with our maintenance app: Work Order Management | Maintenance management in Asset Panda |
Choose ATD if
- You want a published price that you can put in a budget today.
- You want a price for each user that does not grow with the number of items.
- You also want work orders or key control with the same sign-in.
- Your team is in police, fire, EMS, a municipality, or a hospital, and needs printed audit checklists.
Choose Asset Panda if
- Many people must use the system, and you track few items.
- Your team must scan and audit with no signal today.
- You want a free entry option before you pay.
- You want maintenance inside the asset tracking product.
This is our own comparison. Read the full comparison, with its sources and questions.
Key Control Without a Key Cabinet
Electronic key cabinets, such as KeyTrak and KeyWatcher, lock keys away and release each key only to an authorized person. ATD Key Management is software only: it records each key that you issue and get back, and works with the key storage that you have now.
| ATD Key Management | Electronic key cabinets (KeyTrak, KeyWatcher) | |
|---|---|---|
| What you buy | Software only | KeyTrak Edge: a computerized locking steel drawer with iButton key tags. KeyWatcher: a key cabinet with SmartKeys. |
| Price | $40 for each user each month, or $40 with yearly billing | By quote; no prices on the makers' websites |
| Locks keys until an authorized person signs in | No; it records each issue and return | Yes |
| How people sign in | On a computer or a phone | At the cabinet; KeyTrak Edge has a fingerprint reader |
| Overdue keys | Shown at the top of each page, with the name of each key holder | KeyTrak: push alerts in its mobile app for overdue keys, open drawers, and power cuts |
| Setup | Sign up online; no installation | Installation on site |
| Keys that people keep for days or months | Yes, with a due date for each key | Tracks each key as it leaves and returns to the cabinet |
Choose ATD if
- People keep keys for days, weeks, or months.
- Your keys are in many buildings or sites.
- You want to start this week, with no hardware to buy or install.
- You manage a master key system and need a record of each level and each copy.
Choose a key cabinet if
- Many people take the same keys out and put them back each day.
- Keys must stay locked until an authorized person signs in.
- The keys are in one place, such as a vehicle lot or a front desk.
This is our own comparison. Read the full comparison, with its sources and questions.